Malaysiakini
ENBM中文TA
Sign In
Subscribe
  • LifetimeACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Registered on:Renews on:Expires on:
    ACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Extend Subscription
  • Settings
  • Contact Support
  • Sign Out
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
Malaysiakini
user
Sign In
Subscribe
ENBM中文TA
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
ENBM中文TA

      ANNOUNCEMENT

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      It is time Dr M differentiates Jews from Zionists
      Malaysiakini
      News
      It is time Dr M differentiates Jews from Zionists

      It is time Dr M differentiates Jews from Zionists

      Kua Kia SoongPublished: Jan 28, 2019 7:36 AM | Updated: Jan 28, 2019 7:46 AM

      COMMENT | At the outset, let me make it clear that as far as the Palestinian cause is concerned, I am on the same page as Dr Mahathir Mohamad, although I cannot vouch for his consistency on all the other non-Muslim liberation causes in the rest of the world.

      What is disturbing is that through the years, we have witnessed Mahathir’s deliberate refusal to make any distinction between the Jewish people and the ideology of Zionism. This has huge consequences for how our prime minister stands on racism and racial discrimination in our own country... 

      On Israel and Malaysian hypocrisy

      On Israel and Malaysian hypocrisy

      M'sia stripped of hosting rights over Israeli ban; PAS credited for BN win

      M'sia stripped of hosting rights over Israeli ban; PAS credited for BN win

      M'sia stripped of para swimming championships after Israeli ban

      M'sia stripped of para swimming championships after Israeli ban

      Malaysia is in no position to lecture Israel

      Malaysia is in no position to lecture Israel

      • comments27
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      • comments27
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      Related reports4

      On Israel and Malaysian hypocrisy

      28-01-2019

      M'sia stripped of hosting rights over Israeli ban; PAS credited for BN win

      28-01-2019

      M'sia stripped of para swimming championships after Israeli ban

      27-01-2019

      Malaysia is in no position to lecture Israel

      26-01-2019
      View Comments27

      In any deal, compromises are inevitable. You give some, you take some. The other Party gives some and takes some.In the Middle East , for example, BOTH Israelis and Palestinians must give some; and take some.. Otherwise, there will NEVER be peace. In BREXIT, there is a huge debate in UK Parliament; and there is equally a huge debate in the EU (which consists of 27 nations !) Among UK Parliamentarians there are diverse views on how the BREXIT deal could be done. In the EU, there are also diverse views on the same subject.It is IMPOSSIBLE to satisfy all parties on all issues. They must agree to give some and take some. In the Malaysia-Singapore tussle, there are problems; and they can only be resolved by compromises ( give-and-take ). But on the Water Agreement, is it possible to reverse it? Undoubtedly 3 cents for a thousand gallons of raw water is unreasonable! But the tricky problem is that it was an AGREEMENT cemented donkey years ago. Could you break an Agreement. In the law of contract, as far as I see it, a contract is a contract is a contract! IF it could be broken at will, , then what is the pirpose of a having a contract? It is rather sad and regrettable that it is a bad contract. But, in the 1920s. even ONE cent could buy things! Even in the 1970s, a single house in Taman Midah ( Bolton Garden then ) was only $ 15,000.00! In Lucky Garden, Bangsar, a single storey house ( corner lot ) was $20,000.00 ! So, times have changed; prices have rocketed! Can you compare situations then and now ? What are the prices of houses now ? After the Japanese Occupation in the then Malaya 10 cents was a huge amount! But, as a caveat (?), neighbours like Malaysia and Singapore, could give and take, water agreement notwithstanding! But, never demand; it is bad manners, In all situations, give and take to make peace. In the Middle East, BREXIT in UK-EU, Water Agreement in Malaysia-Singapore, cut a deal! Nobody can have everything! If so, it makes nonsense of negotiation.Yes, the rule of law must always prevail.

      ONG JIAN WIN03:58 AM, 30 Jan 2019

      Respect Dr. Kua for his objective article on anti-racism, the difference between Jews and Zionism. It is too simplistic to say that all Chniese are rich and all Malays are poor. There are many poor Chinese people just like there  are many poor Malays. Not all Chinese sell fried mee just like not all Malays sell nasi lemak! And not all Indians sell roti canai, for that matter! To condemn all Jews is wrong . One swallow does not Summer make. You see one swallow, you should not say that Summer  has arrived! Similarly, you should not assume that all British people are drunkards and  sleep just above the pub! Do they ? Weak leaders use race, religion and even royalty to enhance their popularity! Racism, in any nation, not just Malaysia alone, is very bad. Respect all races.  Respect all religions. Pursue your career with all your own effort; never use race and religion.  Hard work pays! Use your brain  which God has given you to the  best of your ability.

      ONG JIAN WIN03:31 PM, 29 Jan 2019

      Mr. Kua, u are not an expert of Palestinian issue. Stop this crap. U are alway so fill of crap trying to confuse the people.

      mama02:41 AM, 29 Jan 2019

      Comments0

      By posting a comment, you agree to our Commenting Terms and Conditions as stipulated in full here.

      Do's and don'ts when posting comments in Malaysiakini

      TERMS & CONDITIONS

      Foul language, profanity, vulgarity, slanderous, personal attack, threatening, sexually-orientated comments or the use of any method of communication that may violate any law or create needless unpleasantness will not be tolerated. Antisocial behaviour such as "spamming" and "trolling" will be suspended. Violators run the risk of also being blocked permanently.

      REPORT VIOLATORS

      Please use the report feature that is available below each comment to flag offending comments for our moderators to take action. Do not take matters in your own hands to avoid unpleasant and unnecessary exchanges that may result in your own suspension or ban.

      NOTICE

      Our commenting system is still under development. We have taken note of feedback provided.

      Subscriber-only space:

      Are you a subscriber?

      Sign In

      Not yet a subscriber?

      Subscribe

      3200 characters remaining

      Pending comments0

      In any deal, compromises are inevitable. You give some, you take some. The other Party gives some and takes some.In the Middle East , for example, BOTH Israelis and Palestinians must give some; and take some.. Otherwise, there will NEVER be peace. In BREXIT, there is a huge debate in UK Parliament; and there is equally a huge debate in the EU (which consists of 27 nations !) Among UK Parliamentarians there are diverse views on how the BREXIT deal could be done. In the EU, there are also diverse views on the same subject.It is IMPOSSIBLE to satisfy all parties on all issues. They must agree to give some and take some. In the Malaysia-Singapore tussle, there are problems; and they can only be resolved by compromises ( give-and-take ). But on the Water Agreement, is it possible to reverse it? Undoubtedly 3 cents for a thousand gallons of raw water is unreasonable! But the tricky problem is that it was an AGREEMENT cemented donkey years ago. Could you break an Agreement. In the law of contract, as far as I see it, a contract is a contract is a contract! IF it could be broken at will, , then what is the pirpose of a having a contract? It is rather sad and regrettable that it is a bad contract. But, in the 1920s. even ONE cent could buy things! Even in the 1970s, a single house in Taman Midah ( Bolton Garden then ) was only $ 15,000.00! In Lucky Garden, Bangsar, a single storey house ( corner lot ) was $20,000.00 ! So, times have changed; prices have rocketed! Can you compare situations then and now ? What are the prices of houses now ? After the Japanese Occupation in the then Malaya 10 cents was a huge amount! But, as a caveat (?), neighbours like Malaysia and Singapore, could give and take, water agreement notwithstanding! But, never demand; it is bad manners, In all situations, give and take to make peace. In the Middle East, BREXIT in UK-EU, Water Agreement in Malaysia-Singapore, cut a deal! Nobody can have everything! If so, it makes nonsense of negotiation.Yes, the rule of law must always prevail.

      ONG JIAN WIN03:58 AM, 30 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Respect Dr. Kua for his objective article on anti-racism, the difference between Jews and Zionism. It is too simplistic to say that all Chniese are rich and all Malays are poor. There are many poor Chinese people just like there  are many poor Malays. Not all Chinese sell fried mee just like not all Malays sell nasi lemak! And not all Indians sell roti canai, for that matter! To condemn all Jews is wrong . One swallow does not Summer make. You see one swallow, you should not say that Summer  has arrived! Similarly, you should not assume that all British people are drunkards and  sleep just above the pub! Do they ? Weak leaders use race, religion and even royalty to enhance their popularity! Racism, in any nation, not just Malaysia alone, is very bad. Respect all races.  Respect all religions. Pursue your career with all your own effort; never use race and religion.  Hard work pays! Use your brain  which God has given you to the  best of your ability.

      ONG JIAN WIN03:31 PM, 29 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Mr. Kua, u are not an expert of Palestinian issue. Stop this crap. U are alway so fill of crap trying to confuse the people.

      mama02:41 AM, 29 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      It is ok to be anti-black people, but not anti-Semitic. Semitic people are God chosen people and must be treated ‘special’ as otherwise the wrath of God will befall upon these anti-Semitic peoples.

      Md Hilmi Md Noor04:55 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      UN recognition of Israel in 1948 meant the Crusaders finally managed to win the Biblical holy lands and chase out the intruders.When Tel Aviv abandoned the word Palestine in favour of Israel, the Arabs in the Biblical holy lands claimed to be Palestinians.Mahathir is not interested in the plight of the so-called Palestinians. He only wants to woo Malay votes to PH. Except for the Gen Y, Malays will not support PH no matter how much the gov't favours them. This is the result of Mahathir brainwashing Malays for 22 years.First things first.Mahathir should put his money where his mouth is and advise the people in the West Bank and Gaza to elect their leaders.No need to send an aid-carrying ship of instant noodles to Israel. The Tel Aviv gov’t is more than capable of looking after the people.In the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Hamas and Fatah leaders have never been elected in the last quarter century.They have no legitimacy.They can’t claim to represent the people in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.That’s why the Gov’t of Israel ignores them.The people of the West Bank and Gaza must elect leaders who can represent them in talks with Israel.The unelected leaders are corrupt, only interested in filling their pockets with aid money and the taxes collected by Israel in the two disputed territories i.e. West Bank and Gaza.

      kay koh03:22 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      The reality is that various Churches own all the land in Jerusalem.Even the Israeli gov’t has to lease land from the Churches.Jerusalem has been majority Jewish ever since it was founded 3, 000 years ago by King David.Islam has run out of time in the Biblical holy lands. The Ottomon Empire never recognised the land claims of the people who now call themselves Palestinians.Except for those Muslims who are Israeli citizens, other Muslim immigrants can only stay in the Biblical holy lands as stateless people.The Biblical lands is not the homeland of the Arabs. Except for the Arabs, all foreign occupiers of the Biblical lands have left.In the last 2, 000 years, Jerusalem came under various foreign rulers.The last was the British.Jerusalem has never been partitioned in the last 3, 000 years. Don’t expect the people to agree to partition the city and hand over the eastern part to unelected leaders in West Bank and Gaza.Israel is a democracy.You can take matters to the Supreme Court.Many Muslims have petitioned the Supreme Court and won against the Israeli gov’t. This includes land issues.On paper, a gov’t can do whatever it wants unless restrained by the court or the people taking to the streets.

      kay koh03:21 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      He was a narrow minded menace back in the old days and is showing his stripes again. Get rid of this old wood from modern politics asap. He is dragging the nation down to his low common denominator - all about race and privilege. He claims to be a simple man with simple needs - but look at his family wealth - ... Marina is the only true spirit - but she has been quickly push aside and silenced. There is no room for her in his macho, bumi, elite, homophobic and racist world. Tun got rid of Najib - bravo - but now - how to get rid of this ill-educated racist dinosaur?

      ooi ah cheng02:17 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Tun is the same racist person. He will not change forever. Currently the nons are in all the key ministry to clean the mess caused by his own race. Upon cleaning, they will be asked to go back to their own country. I don't believe this old man.

      you hock01:37 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Thank for pointing out that the Israeli question is not black and white. In 2016 Jews made up only about 75% of the Israelis, while almost 18% are Muslim. Christians and other religions make up the rest. I know from personal experience that many Israeli Jews don’t practice any religion. So the issue is with the political nation of Israel and the current conservative controlled government. Saudi Arabia is currently committing war crimes against Yemen but no objections are raised against them.

      Baji Thomas12:37 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      As I read more into anti-Zionism, there are many things that surprise.  Do you know that the WCC (World Council of Churches) representing half a billion Christians worldwide, is fundamentally opposed to the state of Israel?  The WCC supports the Palestinians: “the Israeli occupation of Palestinian land is a sin against God and humanity because it deprives the Palestinians of their basic human rights" according to WCC.  Food for thought before we keep blasting Tun.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Council_of_Churches#Opposition_to_Christian_Zionism

      Justin Teoh12:06 PM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Fungus already growing in this oldman's brain. Time to go. Misplaced intelligence, most brillant and seasoned in racial and religious politics. I am having serious doubts about his real intentions. Getting really state and the decay has set in slowlybut surely. His only intention is to rid off the ex PM , rest staus quo... still thesame old shit... using The non- Malays to do his dirty job.

      ZHENLING CHEN10:59 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Mahathir is not an intellectual who makes fine distinctions about Jews, Zionists and Israelis. He just hates them all.

      Jie Hashim10:55 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Further to TCM's point that barring Israel could inadvertantly disadvantage Israeli citizens/swimmers of Arab descent, it's the same as this evil old man (when PM in an earlier regime in the 90's) denying Kelantan of its rightful oil royalty, thus denying UMNO supporters in that state of fallout benefits. He is so evil he didn't and doesn't care

      Maggie Cheong10:55 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      "Foreign Minister Saifuddin Abdullah said the Cabinet affirmed that no Israeli delegates can enter Malaysia for sporting or other events in solidarity with the Palestinians" . Now Malaysia cannot organise  any international meeting where Israelis are participants. This will mean that medical, engineering, trade or any any other World Congress cannot be held in Malaysia. This will affect the livelihood of thousands of Malaysians who are involved in the tourist industry. More and more I think it was a mistake voting for PH in GE 14. The ' shoot your own foot', 'holier than thou' and 'syok sendiri' attitude will  damage the local convention industry.

      PATMANATHAN AYADURAI10:53 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Mr Kua, you said it yourself.  Israel is not made up only of Jews but by Arabs as well (about 20%).  Why do we keep insisting that this stand is anti-Jew and not anti-Israel?  The stand was to bar the Israeli state and that means Jews or Arabs who represent the country would not be able to participate, not only Jews.  If per chance, the Israeli national team consists only of Jews, wouldn't a more pertinent question to ask be "Why"?

      Justin Teoh10:39 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      I won’t blame the ex PM 100% for what he to the country. His mentor has to equally take the blame. If there is one man responsible for the sad state of affairs of our beloved country, it without doubt goes to him. He has not changed a bit. Whatever benefit of doubt I gave him has all evaporated.

      Azman Haziq10:11 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      The hatred of the Jews by the Malays has its genesis in the Koran as per the citations provided by dswami. This hatred has served the Malays and Malay politicians like Mahathir well, who as history shows, have a constant, pathological and compelling need to demonise some other to feel better about themselves, their race, culture and faith. Their hatred is visceral which is why the intellectual ability to discriminate between jews and zionists simply cannot kick in regardless of which foreign university they have attended...or in which Jew-owned store they regularly shop. But that disability has never bothered them. Why? It helps bring them together as a tribe, aiding and abetting their politics of deception.

      Lai Voon Hon09:55 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      This man once said Chinese are immigrants. Immediately, Dr Kua I believe, said : SO ARE THE MALAYS, HISTORY IS OUR WITNESS. The ignorant among the Malays still believe the old man. The old man should never be trusted. What about his ancestry?

      cary09:45 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      "…the Malays are the rightful owners of Malaya… immigrants (read non-Malay Malaysians) are guests until properly absorbed… immigrants are not truly absorbed until they have abandoned the language and culture of their past.”   Obviously, the Malays don't "own" Sarawak (or Sabah)! If indeed Malays really "owned" Malaya, why deprived Sarawak abd upset Sarawak's chance of hosting the Paralympic Swimming Meet and robbed us Sarawakians of earning a potential revenue of millions of ringgit by wielding the Palestinian weapon, like Swakians caused the sufferings of the Palestinians?! Idiot Racist PM!! Let's exit Malaysia, dear Sarawak and Sarawakians! Who needs enemies with a rabid racist PM like Mahathir? GPS CM Abang Jo, got the guts to exit Malaysia? We are waiting....and watching....and praying....

      lee choon kheng09:43 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      MAHATHIR'S ONLY CONTRIBUTION TO MSIA HAS BEEN THE OVERTHROW OF NAJIB. MAHATHIR HAS NOW OUTLIVED HIS USEFULNESS AND SHOULD BE PUT OUT TO GRASS BEFORE HE BECOMES EVEN MORE OF A "MENACE TO HIS OWN PEOPLE AND COUNTRY".

      teo boon chin09:01 AM, 28 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

      This action cannot be undone.

      Report this comment

      500 characters remaining
      mk-logo
      • whatsapp
      • telegram
      • youtube
      • facebook
      • x
      • instagram
      • tiktok
      • linkedin
      • About Us
      • Our Team
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Service
      • Advertise with Us
      • Careers
      • Archive
      • Digital Network
      • KiniTV
      • FG Media
      • RSS Feeds
      • News
      • Opinion
      • Letters
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+6017-323 0707
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      • Advertising
      • advertise@malaysiakini.com
      • advertise@fgmedia.my
      Mkini Dotcom Sdn Bhd
      (199901014818 / 489718-U)No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+603-7770 0017
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      @Kini
      No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor