Malaysiakini
ENBM中文TA
Sign In
Subscribe
  • LifetimeACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Registered on:Renews on:Expires on:
    ACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Extend Subscription
  • Settings
  • Contact Support
  • Sign Out
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
Malaysiakini
user
Sign In
Subscribe
ENBM中文TA
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
ENBM中文TA

      ANNOUNCEMENT

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      BN’s victory gives Harapan a much-needed jolt
      Malaysiakini
      Opinions
      BN’s victory gives Harapan a much-needed jolt

      BN’s victory gives Harapan a much-needed jolt

      Francis Paul SiahPublished: Jan 27, 2019 12:19 AM | Updated: Jan 27, 2019 5:08 AM

      COMMENT Three days ago on Jan 23, I shared my thoughts on the Cameron Highlands by-election with some friends, penning this message: “I hope BN wins. Why?

      “I always look at the candidates, not the party. BN’s Ramli (Mohd Nor) is a fresh face, a tough ex-cop, not entangled in dirty party politics before. He will be a welcome change in Parliament.

      “DAP’s M Manogaran might be a known fighting cock but a tired, same-old, same-old face in Parliament. He is a former Teluk Intan MP.

      “If I am a voter in Cameron Highlands, my vote will go to Ramli also because I think Pakatan Harapan could do with a little jolt. A government in power must not be invincible.

      “Whoever wins, the people of Cameron Highlands will get the development and government assistance as promised. So they should be well taken care of. Now, they must vote wisely.

      “Then again, I’m only giving my views from afar. I do not know the candidates personally. Neither am I familiar with Cameron Highlands, save for the tea I enjoy daily from there”, I concluded.

      I was rooting for a BN victory because I would like to see a stronger opposition in the country. Another extra seat for the opposition BN probably means more than another one in the bag for the powerful Pakatan Harapan government.

      Then again, Cameron Highlands was won by the BN, via MIC’s Sivarraajh Chandran in GE14. BN’s victory, in terms of numbers in Parliament, will not really make any difference to both sides.

      But it does make a world of difference as a morale boost for the BN as this is its first win in a by-election since GE14.

      Several contributing factors are quite clear for this BN’s victory. Let me just pin-point two.

      The choice of BN candidate was superb. Ramli Mohd Nor is not a politician and not affiliated to any party. He is an independent candidate riding on the BN platform. He is untainted and carries no ‘baggage’ commonly associated with BN leaders of the past...

      PAS carries BN across finish line in Cameron Highlands

      PAS carries BN across finish line in Cameron Highlands

      Mat Hasan thanks PAS for helping BN retain Cameron

      Mat Hasan thanks PAS for helping BN retain Cameron

      Official: BN retains Cameron, Ramli to be first Orang Asli MP

      Official: BN retains Cameron, Ramli to be first Orang Asli MP

      'PAS-BN cooperation in Semenyih will depend on Cameron result'

      'PAS-BN cooperation in Semenyih will depend on Cameron result'

      • comments41
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      • comments41
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      Related reports4

      PAS carries BN across finish line in Cameron Highlands

      29-01-2019

      Mat Hasan thanks PAS for helping BN retain Cameron

      26-01-2019

      Official: BN retains Cameron, Ramli to be first Orang Asli MP

      26-01-2019

      'PAS-BN cooperation in Semenyih will depend on Cameron result'

      26-01-2019
      View Comments41

      Yes, PH gov’t needed much jolt, even if it won. Some of them prefer fighting within or going to the press. They didn’t know the meaning of discipline! Looks very much like a mixed bag of some ‘uneducated’ lots in their crowds. Coming to Cameron Highland, it no big deal. Every one thought PH would lost, by a bigger margin. How to win with a born loser like Mano? Couldn’t even say the right thing! It’s a shame DAP should pick him!

      Abu B Hassan11:24 PM, 27 Jan 2019

      CM by-election proved beyond reasonable doubt that playing racial cards is still the best formula for success. Malaysians should be realistic and pragmatic that its society is still not prepared and ready to discard communal politics and it should be accepted without question. Connected to this, the Chinese, left with no choice, has to support DAP which has the political power and capabilities to protect its rights. While the Malays, they have three choices to pick - Party Bersatu, UMNO and PAS. They will choose the strongest party which they perceive could protect and defend their special position and interests. It is crucial that Party Bersatu be given the necessary help for it to evolve into a strong and a viable party in the PH  coalition link to enable it to attract strong Malay support. If it is weak, the Malays will run in droves to support the other Malay based parties. It will result in the fall of the PH government and the rise of the kleptocratic government.

      Amy Lim01:33 PM, 27 Jan 2019

      The jolt is still many naive and ignorant folks easily misled by racial and religious bigots. So the author should work hard to inform these people about the many scandals of the previous BN government and that Najib is no more PM and Umno is no more the government !

      Augustine Paranabas12:22 PM, 27 Jan 2019

      Comments0

      By posting a comment, you agree to our Commenting Terms and Conditions as stipulated in full here.

      Do's and don'ts when posting comments in Malaysiakini

      TERMS & CONDITIONS

      Foul language, profanity, vulgarity, slanderous, personal attack, threatening, sexually-orientated comments or the use of any method of communication that may violate any law or create needless unpleasantness will not be tolerated. Antisocial behaviour such as "spamming" and "trolling" will be suspended. Violators run the risk of also being blocked permanently.

      REPORT VIOLATORS

      Please use the report feature that is available below each comment to flag offending comments for our moderators to take action. Do not take matters in your own hands to avoid unpleasant and unnecessary exchanges that may result in your own suspension or ban.

      NOTICE

      Our commenting system is still under development. We have taken note of feedback provided.

      Subscriber-only space:

      Are you a subscriber?

      Sign In

      Not yet a subscriber?

      Subscribe

      3200 characters remaining

      Pending comments0

      Yes, PH gov’t needed much jolt, even if it won. Some of them prefer fighting within or going to the press. They didn’t know the meaning of discipline! Looks very much like a mixed bag of some ‘uneducated’ lots in their crowds. Coming to Cameron Highland, it no big deal. Every one thought PH would lost, by a bigger margin. How to win with a born loser like Mano? Couldn’t even say the right thing! It’s a shame DAP should pick him!

      Abu B Hassan11:24 PM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      CM by-election proved beyond reasonable doubt that playing racial cards is still the best formula for success. Malaysians should be realistic and pragmatic that its society is still not prepared and ready to discard communal politics and it should be accepted without question. Connected to this, the Chinese, left with no choice, has to support DAP which has the political power and capabilities to protect its rights. While the Malays, they have three choices to pick - Party Bersatu, UMNO and PAS. They will choose the strongest party which they perceive could protect and defend their special position and interests. It is crucial that Party Bersatu be given the necessary help for it to evolve into a strong and a viable party in the PH  coalition link to enable it to attract strong Malay support. If it is weak, the Malays will run in droves to support the other Malay based parties. It will result in the fall of the PH government and the rise of the kleptocratic government.

      Amy Lim01:33 PM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      The jolt is still many naive and ignorant folks easily misled by racial and religious bigots. So the author should work hard to inform these people about the many scandals of the previous BN government and that Najib is no more PM and Umno is no more the government !

      Augustine Paranabas12:22 PM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Francis, what exactly is the jolt here? That Harapan needs to play the racist and religious cards too, like BN?

      YS.CHAN11:35 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Excellent wake up call and for it to happen only 8 month after May 09 is very fortunate as it gives Harapan a lot of time to recover. 3 currently major negatives behavior part of harapan is begining to exhibit : - an entittlement mentality - I dont owe anything to the rakyaat - mini empire builders within. Hope they realize that Dr M might not be there in GE 15. Please get your house in shape while you still have the guidance of 20 year in leading. I voted for you in GE 14, I hope I still will in GE15 but remember you are not entittled to my vote.

      AHMAD NORDIN11:16 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      If Bersatu keeps indiscriminately accepting application forms from UMNO "frogs ",( like the former CM of Melaka ) it will keep losing seats.

      Dea Zoffmann08:52 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      The real concern is for the UMNO diehards that PAS left an irreversible mark on the selection of UMNO candidates for future elections wherever UMNO is contesting. The traditional supporters of UMNO are not at all happy with such a scenario is emerging with the PAS pact.  UMNO diehards knew what they did to BN component parties on the seat allocations is coming back haunting now PAS is at the driving seat. PAS doesn't want any strong candidates from UMNO mainstream but non-UMNO affiliated candidates not tainted by UMNO Culture. The PAS's strong influence in CH by-election also made UMNO as an outcast political player for Sabah and Sarawak political pacts. Thus by CH win UMNO PAS limiting their impact in two northern states of Peninsular. For Harapan, CH by-election is a wakeup call to strengthen the party apparatus to convey the governance program on a timely basis to the voters.

      Lam Yuet Kiew08:23 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      The Semenyih  by-election coming up might be a good platform to use to deliver a stronger message  to the PH that the voters will never forget the promises they made in GE 14.

      07:50 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      PH should deliver what has been promised in its manifesto, and should not deliver things that are not in the manifesto, especially something which has already been proven to be a failure, such as another "national car"!

      Ana06:30 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Racism, Ignorance and apathies have won. Period. This is this nation's shortcoming

      Hisham05:25 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Agree that a strong opposition is good to make sure the current government do not become too strong.  Capable and honest candidates are equally important who should focus on the real issues of the constituency.  The problem is that the focus on racial line as what is being narrated by the opposition parties throughout the campaign.  This will not help improve the people livelihood and the country.  The government in power need to take this opportunity over the 5 years before the next GE to improve the rural folks livelihood and show them the world.

      bee soon yean05:14 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      It's a serious warning alarm for PH from the people. Several Ministers and Deputies and political appointees are very incompetent, inefficient, lacking in experiences and wisdom and EQ undermining the people's basic rights thus not right persons selected based on meritocracy PROMISED for the positions, should be replaced as soon as possible before inviting more dissents  and dissatisfaction from supporters.

      Alimu Sakuredu05:05 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Yes teach PH a lesson in the Semenyih by-election especially Bersatu. Taking us for a ride by accepting frogs from Umno. They should focus on the economy instead of looking after their own interests.

      Chin Weng Wah04:45 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      No credit to Umno/PAS for this victory. There is nothing more disgusting than a victory based on race and religious extremism with toxic mix of hate speeches. The very fact that even baggage laden Najib could deliver makes the victory a spurious one. This victory is seen as gifted to Ramli by those Harapan supporters in CH that wanted to send a clear message to Bersatu hegemony and its subservient components, playing safe and feathering their own nests, that have strayed from their election promises of corruption free colour blind reformist governance. The CH election is a sampling of what will be the trend in future by-elections if Harapan leaders do not stop politicking, manipulation and scrambling for power and continue cheating those that put them in power in so far as the election manifesto promises. They do so at their own peril in GE15.

      ivan teo04:21 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Yes, give PH another lesson in Semenyih by ensuring PH lose badly in the coming byelection. Don't take voters for fools, making empty promises in their manifesto. We want to see the process started to fulfill the promises in the manifesto, not giving silly excuses for doing nothing. Give us voters a plan on how you are going to fulfill your promises. Hope PSM will contest the Semenyih byelection and win instead of BN.

      Parvinder Kaur04:12 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Hopefully PH will now not bend fully towards the Malays a 100% like what Najib did.

      Gary Lim04:05 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Fairplayer...perhaps you didnt take into account that you are living in Malaysia and by whatever formation you choose, you are still and will face with a Malay majority party and headed by a Malay like Mahathir.  Worst still, if that someone lack guts to even make U turn or decisive action.  How many other past PM that you think made a good performance?  You have better options in hand?  Reshuffling or kicking any parties out at infancy stage may not be wise, especially they were tied by loose ends.  Patient is the key for now.

      Ayesha Sarkar03:58 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Agreed!

      Teng Chang Khim03:56 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      It doesn't bode well for the future of  Malaysia with this BN victory although many says it is a wake up call for PH. The big issue and concern is the mentality of the hinterland malays and has far reaching consequences other than just jolting up the PH government. This BN victory is fought using Race and Religion and they won. For one, this will only encourage the continuity of such dispicable tactics - lying, dividing the races. Secondly, the extremist elements within PH especially those in Bersatu will see the result as an affirmation of their strategy of using Race & Religion and for good measure also throw in the "by hook or by crook" underhand tactics. It will be more difficult for the PH leaders to rein these extremist elements in now. The reality is that Malaysian politics is driven by the hinterland malays and with this siege mentality, we are fighting against the current to bring stability and prosperity to the nation. We all hope that the PH government to leaders has the courage, political will and commitment to fight this battle which will be long and hard.

      orchid03:55 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      good job....im a  pakatan voter...but i am warning  PH.....listen to the roots..dont renegade on your promises...or we will throw you out too...manogaran deserves it  as he put his foot in his  mouth.....many times..and wearing the  shirt too...an  election offence.....well deserved win..the people taught the PH  a  lessson they will never forget...be humble and tepati janji janji semua

      willie03:50 AM, 27 Jan 2019
      3200 characters remaining

      Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

      This action cannot be undone.

      Report this comment

      500 characters remaining
      mk-logo
      • whatsapp
      • telegram
      • youtube
      • facebook
      • x
      • instagram
      • tiktok
      • linkedin
      • About Us
      • Our Team
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Service
      • Advertise with Us
      • Careers
      • Archive
      • Digital Network
      • KiniTV
      • FG Media
      • RSS Feeds
      • News
      • Opinion
      • Letters
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+6017-323 0707
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      • Advertising
      • advertise@malaysiakini.com
      • advertise@fgmedia.my
      Mkini Dotcom Sdn Bhd
      (199901014818 / 489718-U)No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+603-7770 0017
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      @Kini
      No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor